Updated June 10, 2021
This post contains affiliate links, you can catch our full disclaimer at the bottom of this post.
It is important to read a number of baby crib reviews before purchasing a crib. The most important information to look for is the current guidelines about the crib’s safety and quality of construction.
Quality and safety often go hand-in-hand because poor construction often leads to an unsafe product.
When reading a review about baby cribs also look at the crib’s retail history.
- Does the crib have a good consumer record (no recalls) since it was released?
- Have any defects been reported to the manufacturer?
- Has the crib been sited for manufacturing defects? Are there any injuries to babies that have been reported by one or more consumers?
When you start shopping for a crib, remember that most parents are very selective consumers. Millennials, in particular, are very computer savvy shoppers. They know how to thoroughly research a particular product before ever setting foot into a store.
If a particular baby crib has been popular among parents for a long time, that is a good sign. However, it is still important to make sure the crib you select is compliant with the most recent safety guidelines.
Once you have completed your online research for the best baby crib reviews, you will likely find that parents ultimately do make the right decision.
Read as many reviews as possible, keeping in mind what crib features will best serve your needs. It is very easy to lose sight of what matters to you. Reviews can be very informative but may steer you towards features you don’t need.
The last step before going to the store to evaluate the physical product is to cross-check the information you have learned with a few well-established, authoritative websites such as the CDC, CPSC, and Consumer Reports.
Baby cribs are often recalled and for good reason.
During your research, you will likely come across cribs that have been recalled. A recall might be because of a large number of negative reviews or as a result of accidents or injuries related to a manufacturing or design flaw.
While on the topic of safety, it is important to note that old cribs (family heirlooms, etc.) are not to be used for your newborn. This is based on what we have learned over many years about structural crib safety and toxic materials.
This post may contain affiliate links, you can catch our full disclaimer at the bottom of this post.
Baby Crib Safety Guidelines:
Safety guidelines are often updated as a result of tragic, real-life events. Unfortunately, manufacturers do try to anticipate any potential safety concerns before the release of a product to consumers.
In the same way, safety regulatory commissions try to identify the potential danger of a product before it is sold. In spite of these efforts, it is hard to prevent all tragedies.
Seatbelts and child car seats are excellent examples of products that became commonplace in our society as a result of data accrued based on user experience. As we see in these situations, the products are now legally required.
There was a time when children rode in cars, completely unrestrained. It is hard for parents who were brought up using seatbelts to imagine a time when children restraints did not exist. Again, it is not the fault of safety commissioners or the auto industry.
The introduction of restraints for children resulted from data accrued clearly indicating a need for baby car carriers.
We now know that child restraint systems save lives. The thought of not having a child securely fastened in a car that is moving is no longer on the minds of most parents. This is because the parent of today’s children grew up with seatbelts and child car seats.
It is important to note that many old cribs had serious safety concerns and must not be used. As we have mentioned, at the time they were designed and constructed to comply with the safety standards that were in place at that time.
The certified websites listed below address the safety guidelines for cribs. This is information you will want to review before purchasing any crib for your baby. Baby crib reviews are a great way to compare cribs to decide on the type of crib you want and what features you desire.
The information is based on real-life statistics that have been accrued over many decades. Safety information is constantly changing because it is based on findings once a product has been put into use by many people.
Make sure the crib you select :
- Meets the latest government safety standards
- Has not been recalled
- Is popular among new parents
Crib Safety Requirements:
Before reading the five best baby crib reviews it is very important to make the crib you select is certified and meets or exceeds all safety guidelines.
- Juvenile Products Manufacturers Association (JPM)
- Consumer Product Safety Commission (CPSC)
- American Society for Testing Materials (ASTM)
- For over 10 years this crib has been listed among the top cribs for safety, construction, and ease of assembly.
- The crib is environmentally friendly, constructed of 100% New Zealand pine wood.
- For those on a budget who do not want to compromise safety, the DaVinci Kalani 4 in 1 Convertible Crib is competitively priced.
The 5 Best Baby Crib Reviews For 2019:
(In no particular order)
The Storkcraft Tuscany 4-in-1 Convertible Crib is attractive and made from top quality materials. This crib is the best-selling Storkcraft Crib.
It features a three-position adjustable height mattress and will easily convert to a toddler bed, daybed and full-size bed.
The sleigh bed design is very popular. This theme has a number of accessory furnishings including a changing table, chest, dresser, and a glider chair, and ottoman.
StorkCraft nursery furniture has many furnishings for your entire nursery using the same theme.
The Evolur Signature Cape May 5-in-1 Full Panel Convertible Crib is a luxury crib made of kiln-dried hardwood. Its surface is made of a fine veneer.
This crib is designed to accommodate your baby as she grows. There are 3 mattress levels and it has a fixed stationary side rail. It can be converted into a toddler bed and full-size bed with back panels and a bed frame (parts are sold separately).
The crib is designed and engineered to meet all the safety standards required (above) and is subjected to independent laboratory testing.
The Cape May crib is designed to complement a beach house decor. This crib is crafted with decorative molding to create the look you desire. It is important to mention that this crib is the priciest in this review because of the design detail and quality of materials.
The Evolur Signature Cape May 5-in-1 Full Panel Convertible Crib has matching furniture including a Cap May Chest.
The Delta Children Canton 4-in-1 Convertible Baby Crib in the Espresso Cherry finish offers the value of converting your child’s crib to a toddler bed, daybed and ultimately a full-sized bed.
This bed will grow with your baby and has three mattress levels.
The crib’s sturdy wood construction will remain structurally sound for many years and meets all the safety guidelines for cribs established by the JPMA, CPSC, and ASTM.
The company also performs tests to screen for toxic elements. Their testing exceeds the government standards set by ASTM.
The crib is very easy to assemble and free replacement parts are readily available. If the style of the crib fits in with your home decor, you will be pleased with the sleek sleigh bed design.
The StorkCraft Portofino 4-in-1 fixed side convertible crib, and changer is extremely versatile to make your life a little easier.
During infancy, the changing table adjacent to the StorkCraft Crib is very convenient. As your child grows the crib converts into a toddler bed, daybed and even a full-size bed.
The StorkCraft company has been manufacturing quality baby furniture for 70 years. The company encourages parents to compare their product to other manufacturers.
Storkcraft Baby Furniture received the 2018 Women’s Choice Award. In 2018, they were America’s most recommended baby furniture company.
Storkcraft furniture also makes matching dressers and glider rocking chairs. These furnishings are very helpful when it comes to designing your nursery.
The crib has a large storage capacity, including three drawers and three open shelves. The changing table is designed to stand alone until your child is ready to sleep in a toddler bed.
The StorkCraft Portofino 4-in-1 fixed side convertible crib and changer meets all the safety requirements published by the JPMA, CPSC, and ASTM.
The DaVinci Kalani 4-in-1 Convertible Crib in the Espresso finish is beautifully crafted, extremely versatile, and competitively priced.
This crib is sturdy and can be converted to a toddler bed, daybed, or full-size bed. The quality of construction is excellent. It is made of 100% New Zealand pinewood.
The DaVinci Collection company takes pride in its products. They are constructed from the best materials. For over the past 10 years, DaVinci cribs have been among the highest-rated cribs when it comes to safety, sturdiness, and ease of assembly.
The DaVinci Kalani 4-in-1 Convertible Crib is reasonably priced and still includes the features offered with the higher-priced cribs.
This is our top pick for “Best Baby Cribs Of 2019”:
Guidelines For Buying and Safely Using A Baby Crib:
(This information is based on what is known about crib-related injuries at the time of this publication and is not all-inclusive.)
In 2010 the Consumer Product Safety Commission (CPSC) banned the use of cribs with dropdown side rails. The video below was published in 2009 and discusses this concern. By 2010, there were approximately 32 infant deaths attributed to cribs with dropdown side rails. This finding led to a ban on cribs with dropdown side rails.
1. The slats on the side of a crib cannot be wider than 2 ⅜ inches apart. This is a manufacturing safety guideline.
2. If the crib has wheels, make sure they can be locked securely. Wheels on cribs should be removed if the nursery floor is tile or wood.
3. Try to avoid purchasing a crib that has a lot of decorations. If you do, make sure you remove any decorations attached to the headboard and footboard.
4. Put your hands down the side of the crib mattress and make sure the mattress is snug against the sides of the crib.
5. The height of the crib railings must be 26 inches above the mattress. As your infant grows you will need to adjust the side rails. Baby’s are very resourceful and often find ways to climb out of cribs which can lead to serious injuries.
6. Make sure to purchase a firm crib mattress for your newborn. This will prevent your baby’s face from sinking into the bedding which can obstruct breathing.
7. Don’t put stuffed animals in your baby’s crib. Years ago, it was not uncommon to put many items in a crib for play and comfort. This has changed based on research done on Sudden Infant Death Syndrome (SIDS). For information about SIDS visit: Safe Sleep Basics
8. Keep items out of the crib. This will prevent your child from using items to climb over the side rails.
9. If you plan to assemble your baby’s furniture, follow the instructions closely and make you test the crib when you are done to make sure it functions properly. Check for sturdiness and how stable the crib is when setting it on the floor.
*Years ago, almost all furniture was constructed in a factory. These days, assembling furniture at home has become very popular. The reason for this is because transportation is easier and the furniture is less expensive. Many parents no longer purchase high-end, costly furniture due to budgetary concerns or simply because infants and toddlers grow out of their furniture so quickly.
10. Always keep other furnishings: stools, rockers, large toys, benches away from the crib. Otherwise, your child will use these items to climb into the crib.
11. When assembling the crib yourself, make sure there are no loose or missing parts when you are done. If it is assembled at the store for you you will also want to be careful. Many DIY furnishings are assembled at the store by hired help. These individuals are not affiliated with the crib company and assemble any DIY furniture. For this reason, you will want to make sure the crib was assembled properly.
12. If the crib has raised posts at the corners, they should not be higher than 1/16”. Almost flush so they cannot catch on any clothing.
13. Do not put pillows, comforters, blankets or sheepskins in your newborn’s crib. Extra bedding in cribs can be harmful based on current (SIDS) research.
14. Wedges should never be used. They can change the sleep position of your baby. This has been associated with an increased risk of SIDS. Another reason babies should not use wedges is that they can use them to climb over the side rail.
15. If you have your baby sleep in your room, this has been shown to reduce SIDS by up to 50%. The American Academy of Pediatrics recommends newborns sleep in their parents’ room for at least the first 6 months and preferably the first year.
If you want your newborn to sleep in your room but not in a bassinet or cot (co-sleeper), there are options. Consider purchasing a crib that can be transported from one room to another. This can also be helpful if your baby is sick and you want your child close to you during the night.
A Pack N’ Play is what we have most recently used.
*** Do not have your baby sleep in your bed. There are a number of reasons why this is not safe. (Source) It is recommended to use an approved baby cot adjacent to your bed, a bassinet or your newborn’s crib.
Sleeping in the same room also makes breastfeeding easier and has been associated with a decrease in SIDS. (Source)
The Consumer Products Safety Commission (CPSC) also states that you should never use second-hand cribs for two main reasons:
- Older baby cribs lack the most recent safety guidelines.
- Many older cribs have been assembled and disassembled many times. This can make the cribs structurally unsafe.
Stop Using Recalled Simplicity Drop-Side Cribs
Courtesy of: US Consumer Product Safety Commission (CPSC)
What to read next: